Vince Lombardis Steak House Menu (Update 2025)
Welcome to Vince Lombardi's Steak House, a distinguished destination for steak lovers in Appleton, WI. Located at 333 W College Ave, this culinary gem offers a menu that delights the senses and elevates the dining experience.
The starters are a celebration of flavor, with options like the Gulf Shrimp Cocktail and Wagyu Cheesesteak Spring Roll tantalizing your palate. For the main course, the 10oz Prime Filet Mignon takes center stage, perfectly cooked to your desired doneness, while the indulgent Smoked Gouda & Truffle Lobster Mac redefines comfort food. Don’t miss the 22oz Porterhouse for a real treat.
Compliment your meal with fresh salads such as the Lombardi Caesar, and conclude with decadent desserts like the Chocolate Lava Cake, as praised by many satisfied guests. The exceptional service, highlighted by attentive staff, makes each visit memorable. Come experience the culinary excellence at Vince Lombardi’s, where every dish tells a story!
Starters
Bang Bang Shrimp
cabbage slaw | peanuts | togarashi
Burrata di Bufala
basil sauce | heirloom tomato jam | crispy coppa | baguette
Chilled Jumbo Lump Crabmeat
drawn butter
Gulf Shrimp Cocktail
sambal cocktail sauce | charred lemon
Tuna Poke
ponzu | seaweed | avocado | wonton chips
Wagyu Cheesesteak Spring Roll
Australian wagyu short rib | smoked provolone | charred green onion | crème
10oz Prime Filet Mignon
14oz NY Strip
16oz 35 Day Dry-Aged Kansas City Strip
16oz Porterhouse Porkchop
chipotle lime butter
18oz Bone-In Filet
18oz Cajun Ribeye
22oz Bone-In Ribeye
22oz Porterhouse
35oz Bone-In Tomahawk Ribeye
5oz Maine Lobster Tail
6oz Prime Filet Mignon
Chilean Seabass
basil crème reduction
Half Brick Chicken
chili-basil vinaigrette | crispy thyme potato
Jumbo Lump Crab Cake
Lamb Loin Chops
Smoked Gouda & Truffle Lobster Mac
white truffle | cavatappi pasta | buttered chive panko crumble
Three Jumbo Grilled Shrimp
Twin Maine Lobster Tail
charred lemon | drawn butter
Veal Picatta
white wine | caperberries | whole butter
Mains
Soup & Salad
Chopped Salad
olives | roasted red pepper | bacon | lardons heirloom tomatoes | cucumber | olive oil | white balsamic vinegar | mozzarella cheese
Five Onion Soup Gratine
swiss cheese | Satorini SarVecchio | french bread crouton
Iceberg Wedge
Roth buttermilk bleu cheese | cherry tomato | bacon | pickled red onion
Lobster Bisque
crème fraiche | chives | sherry
Lombardi Caesar
romaine hearts | flatbread croutons | Sartori SarVecchio
Asparagus
fritti or grilled | hollandaise
Crispy Brussels Sprouts
bourbon maple | balsamic reduction
Crispy Potatoes
taleggio cheese sauce | honey thyme butter
Grilled Broccolini
citrus chili vinaigrette | panko parmesan crumble
Maitake Mushrooms
black umami garlic butter | herb trio
Sea Salt Baked Potato
sour cream | thyme
Smashed Cheddar Red Bliss Potatoes
Twice Baked
Hook's cheddar | Nueske's bacon | scallions
Whole Baby Burgundy Mushrooms
with or without onion
Accompaniments
Additions
Au Poivre
Bearnaise
Black Umami Garlic Steak Butter
Crust
blackened porcini | herb bleu cheese | cracked peppercorn
Demi-Glace
Hollandaise
Horseradish Crème
Oscar
Chicken Tenders
with fries
Grilled Cheese
with fries
Milk Orange Juice Cranberry Juice Shirley Temple Roy Rogers
skim | 2% | chocolate